Everton suffered a narrow 1-0 defeat to Arsenal at Goodison Park on December 20, 2025. A result that has left the Toffees furious. Martin Ødegaard’s first-half strike proved decisive, but the real talking point emerged in the 57th minute when a potential game-changer was overlooked involving William Saliba.
The controversial clash
The incident unfolded as Everton pushed for an equalizer. Striker Thierno Barry latched onto a loose ball in the Arsenal box, before defender William Saliba challenged aggressively. Barry touched the ball first. However, William Saliba’s boot connected exactly to the attacker’s standing leg – no contact with the ball. Referee Sam Barrott allowed the game to continue and VAR Michael Salisbury deemed it unworthy of a review. Replays showed a clear foul that sent Goodison Park into an uproar and shattered Everton’s momentum.
The panel’s damning verdict
In a 3-2 decision, the KMI panel declared Barrott’s decision incorrect, highlighting Saliba’s “careless” challenge as a clear and obvious error that warranted intervention. Three members highlighted Barry’s lack of ball contact and immediate response, while two disagreed, citing insufficient impact. The panel also voted 3-2 that VAR should have prompted an on-field review, potentially changing the course of the match. This ruling underlines the continuing inconsistencies of VAR, with the technology failing to correct a crucial oversight.
Moyes’ fear of outrage and relegation
Everton boss David Moyes did not hold back: ‘I choked last night when I saw the decision made’ [to Fulham] and ours was not. It feels like certain clubs get those decisions and other clubs don’t.” With the Toffes hovering just three points above the drop zone, the denied penalty, if converted, could have provided crucial breathing space. Arsenal, meanwhile, are marching at the top of the table, but the shadow of the controversy lingers.
The lingering shadow of VAR
This episode reinforces calls for VAR reform, especially as the title race heats up. For Everton it is a bitter pill to swallow in a battle for survival, while Arsenal fans brace themselves for the ‘what if’ questions. Like the Premier League As it hurtles towards its climax, such panels serve as a grim reminder: in the quest for perfection, even the smallest contact from start to finish can tip the scales of justice.
As stated on GoonerNews.com
#Arsenals #William #Saliba #slammed #robbing #Everton