Recognizing the Water You’re Swimming in: How Hidden Expectations Shape Your Financial Decisions | Meaningful money

If you don’t know what water you’re swimming in, you can’t choose your direction.

In the adult cartoon Archerthe main character, Sterling Archer, tells his colleague Cyril to take his suit to his tailor and his shoes to his shoemaker.

Cyril asks: “Do you have a cobbler?”

Sterling looks confused. “Isn’t it?”

It’s meant to be funny. It highlights Archer’s unconscious privilege. But beneath the joke lies something deeper: we all assume that our normal is universal.

Sterling spends time with people who own cobblers. It never occurs to him that others don’t.

That’s the first world version of a much broader truth.

We all live within assumptions that we rarely question.

David Foster Wallace once gave a famous speech entitled This is water. In it he described how fish do not notice the water in which they swim. It’s everywhere. It’s invisible. It’s just ‘how things are’.

Most of us go through life unaware of the expectations, cultural norms and social pressures that shape our financial decisions. Becoming aware of that water does not mean rejecting it. It means that you choose more consciously.

We all swim in water that we have not consciously chosen.

– What kind of career feels respectable?

– What “normal” expenses look like

– What retirement should mean

– How busy we think we should be

Most of us don’t wake up one day and decide to join the rat race. We float in it. It feels natural and automatic.

That’s the default that Wallace was talking about. The water defines the rules before we even realize there are rules.

Humans are programmed to survive. For most of history, staying alive was the goal.

But once we’ve taken care of basic survival, we move on to something more complicated: deciding how to live well.

And we are not naturally adept at that.

So we look around. We compare and copy. Psychologists sometimes call this mimetic desire; we want what others want because they want it. The cultural abbreviation is “keeping up with the Joneses.”

Our financial story starts to form almost automatically.

– The spending pattern of our social circle

– The lifestyle expectations of our profession

– The financial philosophy of our family system

– The comparison game of our online feeds

In other words, we hunt with the herd.

The trouble is that we don’t even realize that we are in the herd. It feels normal.

The goal is not to escape the water completely. The goal is to recognize it.

You don’t have to reject your lifestyle. You don’t have to feel guilty about enjoying success. You don’t have to rebel against everything that is known.

You just have to become aware.

Once you recognize the forces pulling at you, you can start asking better questions.

– If you couldn’t tell anyone how you live, how would you live?

– Which financial habits feel ‘automatic’ rather than chosen?

– What would change if you were not observed?

– What assumptions about money have you never questioned?

– What would change if you moved cities, changed industries, or joined a different social circle?

These questions are not intended to disrupt your life overnight, but to wake you up.

Without reflection, it’s easy to sleepwalk through life doing what we think we should do. Sometimes it even feels good… like water to a fish.

But water is not the enemy.

The danger is swimming without realizing you are swimming. Because if you don’t recognize the current, you don’t steer. You are drifting. And by drifting you can end up somewhere you did not consciously choose.

Consciousness gives you something simple and powerful: the freedom to determine your direction.

Interested in more like this? Subscribe and get updates sent straight to you.

If you know someone else who would benefit from reading this post, please share it with them. Spread the word, if you think there is a word to spread.

To share via text, social media or email, simply copy and paste the following link: