Beginning with the 2026-2027 season, the Allstate Homegrown Division will stick with the traditional birth year system that runs from January through December and has been in place since 2017, while the Academy Division will switch to a school year format that runs from August through July. The question becomes why is the United States still so reluctant to fully commit to the birth year model that the rest of the world uses?
It makes sense that the Homegrown division remains based on the year of birth. It affiliates with FIFA, matches every major international competition and paves the way for youth national teams. Coaches know exactly what they are doing, scouts can compare each other and players grow up at the same pace as their peers abroad.
But the Academy Division moving to a school-year timeline tells its own story of U.S. youth soccer. Culturally, the school calendar still determines everything from club schedules to family planning. MLS NEXT tries to meet that reality halfway. The league says this shift will help it adapt to the broader youth landscape, build relationships with more clubs and keep the talent pipeline flowing. It’s an understandable move, but it sits uncomfortably with the standards the league claims it wants to reflect.
Development thrives on clarity. If a player was born in December, his trajectory will look different depending on the division he is in. That kind of inconsistency doesn’t exist abroad. For a country trying to catch up to the top of the world, these small gaps in structure become big gaps in development.
League officials spoke to academy directors, youth leaders, national team staff and club operators from all corners of the system to gain buy-in.
Still, at some point the United States must decide whether it wants to continue operating on two calendars or ultimately join the rest of the soccer world on one calendar. Until then, questions about consistency, scouting and long-term growth will lead nowhere.
Contact the author of this story at force.l1764910918laboratory1764910918ofdlr1764910918are1764910918sni@r1764910918etc1764910918w.kci1764910918N1764910918
#School #year #calendar #year #Growing #Pains #American #Age #Football #World #Football