Was Maryland father deported by Trump as a member of MS-13? Here is the truth about Kilmar Armando Abrego Garcia | World News – The Times of India

In a case that caused the national controversy, the Trump government admitted that it was deported Kilmar Armando Abrego Garcia – A father of Maryland – to El Salvador despite a status immigrantThe order of him protects against removal. Now locked up in the notorious Cecot Mega-Prison of El Salvador, the case of Abrego Garcia raises strong questions about citizenship, wrong identification and the use of questionable gang fertilations in immigration enforcement.
Was Abrego Garcia an American citizen?
No. Abrego Garcia was one Salvadoran NationalNo citizen of the United States. He entered the US around 2011 after emerging Bendegeweld as a teenager and lived in Maryland with his wife and young American son. Although married to an American and legally lives in the country, he never became a naturalized citizen.
His legal presence in the US was based on a protection known as ‘withholding from removal’, which was granted in 2019 by an immigration court. That status is granted when a judge finds that the deportation of someone would expose them to prosecution or torture in their home country. In the case of Abrego Garcia, the judge ruled that he was confronted with credible threats of violence when he returned to El Salvador – especially of the gangs he was accused of.
Despite this protection ordered by the court, Abrego Garcia was arrested in March 2025 by ICE and added to a deportation flight to El Salvador. The government now admits that his removal was an administrative error – he was not supposed to be on the run – but insists that it cannot pick him up because he is now in the detention of Salvadoran.
He was a member of MS-13?
The central justification offered for the arrest and removal of Abrego Garcia was that he was a “ranking” of the MS-13 gang. But that accusation, repeated by top officials, is not supported by a criminal conviction, hard evidence or confirming police reports.
The only basis for the claim seems to be a single informant who told the federal authorities in 2019 that Abego Garcia was affiliated with MS-13.
Immigration rights treated the tip seriously enough to refuse him a bond at the time, stating precautions. However, this does not correspond to a feeling of guilt. Abrego was never accused of a crime, never convicted and had no criminal record in the US
The informant who complicated the government’s case also claimed that Abrego belonged to a specific MS-13 clique that did not even operate in Maryland. The local police reportedly could not verify the information and the officer who documented the claim for the first time was later suspended. There is never independent proof of gang membership produced.
In the meantime, Abrego Garcia consistently denied the allegations and he continued to live peacefully in Maryland for years. He maintained immigration check-ins, worked full-time and raised his child without incidents. The immigration court that granted him protection found that he was in the risk of being part of it – not to be part of it – which further undermines the story of the government.
The last answer
Kilmar Abrego Garcia was not an American citizen, but he was legally protected against deportation because of the real dangers with which he was confronted in El Salvador. The statement of the US government that he was a high-ranking MS-13 member is based on a single non-rewarded informant tip and was never proven in court or supported by independent investigation.
His wrong deportation has now imprisoned him in one of the world’s most brutal prisons – not because of what he did, but because of a bureaucratic mistake and a dubious label. The case reflects the high use of immigration enforcement in an era in which rumors and error can overwrite legal protection and can cost lives.